Meanwhile, an idealistic farmer revives Kansas' progressive tradition, taking his message all the way to Washington, D.C. — Laura Cohen. When business screwed the farmers and the workers – when it implemented monopoly strategies invasive beyond the Populists' furthest imaginings – when it ripped off shareholders and casually tossed thousands out of work – you could be damned sure about what would follow. Publisher's webpage, What's The Matter With "What's The Matter With Kansas", Thomas Frank's own rebuttal to this paper. Frank's thesis goes thus: In order to explain to the "Cons" why no progress gets made on these issues, politicians and pundits point their fingers to a "liberal elite," a straw man representing everything that conservatism is not. by Thomas Frank, a renowned American political analyst and journalist, presents his use of Kansas as an example to show why many Americans vote against their economic and social interests. Parents Guide. … This page was last edited on 11 December 2020, at 18:45. The book was published in Britain and Australia as What's the Matter with America? Lease advised, and she seems tohave an over-production. The Republicans sent out hundreds of thousands of copies of the editorial in support of William McKinley during the 1896 U.S. presidential election. Much of "What's the Matter with Kansas" was a play-by-play rehashing of the news stories that have helped make Kansas the laughing stock of the nation. spent 18 weeks on the New York Times Bestseller List. Meanwhile, an idealistic farmer revives Kansas' progressive tradition, taking his message all the way to Washington, D.C. But that doesn't matter. However, once in office, these politicians turn their attention to more mundane economic issues, such as business tax reduction or deregulation. Nothing under the shining sun. What's the Matter with Kansas? The way to collect the votes and -- more important -- the money of these coveted constituencies, "New Democrats" think, is to stand rock-solid on, say, the pro-choice position while making endless concessions on economic issues, on welfare, NAFTA, Social Security, labor law, privatization, deregulation and the rest of it. the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america 2004 is a book by american journalist and historian thomas frank which explores the rise of populist anti elitist conservatism in the united states centering on the experience of kansas franks native statein the late 19th century says frank kansas was known as a hotbed of the Push them off their land, and next thing you know they're protesting in front of abortion clinics. What's the Matter with Kansas? Frank also claims a bitter divide between 'moderate' and 'conservative' Kansas Republicans (whom he labels "Mods" and "Cons") as an archetype for the future of politics in America, in which fiscal conservatism becomes the universal norm and political war is waged over a handful of hot-button cultural issues. He attributes this partly to conservatives "waging cultural battles where victory is impossible," such as a constitutional amendment banning gay marriage. More than a century later, the phrase was invoked as the title of a book and a film; it has also been used in many other contexts. To differentiate themselves from Republicans at the national level, Democrats also focused on socio-cultural wedge issues: The Democratic Leadership Council, the organization that produced such figures as Bill Clinton, Al Gore, Joe Lieberman and Terry McAuliffe, has long been pushing the party to forget blue-collar voters and concentrate instead on recruiting affluent, white-collar professionals who are liberal on social issues. This theme of victimization by these "elites" is pervasive in conservative literature, despite the fact that at the time conservatives controlled all three branches of government, were being served by an extensive media devoted only to conservative ideology, and had won 6 of the previous 9 presidential elections. Latest posts by Teodrose Fikremariam . is a vivid portrait of an upside-down world where blue-collar patriots recite the Pledge while they strangle their life chances; where small farmers cast their votes for a Wall Street order that will eventually push them off their land; and where a group of frat boys, lawyers, and CEOs has managed to convince the country that it speaks on behalf of … The must-read summary of Thomas Frank's book: “What's the Matter with Kansas? Which Kansas is he? : How Conservatives Won The Heart Of America by Thomas Frank. Strip today's Kansans of their job security, and they head out to become registered Republicans. It looks like we don't have a Synopsis for this title yet. Kansas is allright. With Bill Kurtis, Jack Wright, Laura Kirk, Jim Lehrer. Has the white working class abandoned the Democratic party? By emphasizing issues such as health care and school funding and avoiding hot-button social issues, Sebelius successfully fractured the Kansas GOP and won a clear majority. a politically active Kansas megachurch splinters, moves to an amusement park, and when that fails, a Best Western motel. "[7] Frank provided a lengthy rebuttal to Bartels' analysis. What's the Matter with Kansas? How Conservatives Won the Heart of America is a book by American journalist and historian Thomas Frank, which explores the rise of populist anti-elitist conservatism in the United States, centering on the experience of Kansas, Frank's native state. Plot Keywords What's the Matter with Kansas was an 1896 newspaper editorial. A Kansas megachurch splinters, while a farmer brings a progressive message to Washington. [3], In the study "The Truth about Conservative Christians," two sociologists, Andrew Greeley and Michael Hout, claim to show that class does matter, despite Frank's thesis. The editorial established White's career in journalism. Be the first to contribute! Kansas never did believe indiversified crops. Paraphrases (not excerpts) of early paragraphs from the book. This would have been a political certainty, as predictable as what happens when you touch a match to a puddle of gasoline. ], published by Metropolitan. Frank says that since the coalition formed in the late 1960s, the coalition has been "fantastically rewarding" for the economic conservatives. Directed by Kevin Willmott. Follow Me . Writer at Ghion Journal. Summary: What's the Matter with Kansas? The policies of the Republicans in power have been exclusively economic, but the coalition has caused the social conservatives to be worse off economically, due to these pro-corporate policies. Poorer Protestants, they argue, are much less likely to vote Republican than affluent ones. There’s a lot the matter with Kansas for Philip and Elizabeth, who are loathe to accept a new assignment related to the possible sabotage of Soviet grain by … Kansas, once home to farmers who marched against “money power,” is now solidly Republican. Not these days. And, they claim, conservative Protestants are actually more likely to support progressive taxation than "mainline" Protestants are. Just click the "Edit page" button at the bottom of the page or learn more in the Synopsis submission guide. They argue that the class basis of New Deal coalition had given way to a new structure in which conservative ideology and cultural issues brought large numbers of working-class whites into the Republican camp. About; Latest Posts; Follow Me. | The book also details how Kathleen Sebelius, a Democrat, was elected governor in conservative Kansas. Five Republican presidents — Theodore Roosevelt, William Howard Taft, Warren Harding, Calvin Coolidge, and Herbert Hoover — were to spend nights at his home. Not long ago, Kansas would have responded to the current situation by making the bastards pay. What's The Matter With Kansas? Are religious voters distracted from economic issues? She is losing her wealth, population and standing.She has got her statesmen, and the money power is afraid of her. A brilliant analysis-and funny to boot-What's the Matter with Kansas? "What's the Matter with Kansas" upcoming feature documentary adaptation, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=What%27s_the_Matter_with_Kansas%3F_(book)&oldid=993646626, Books about politics of the United States, Books critical of conservatism in the United States, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, Robert Huckfeldt and Carol Weitzel Kohfeld in. By portraying themselves as champions of the conservatives on these issues, the politicians can get "Cons" to vote them into office. The larger interests that the DLC wants desperately to court are corporations, capable of generating campaign contributions far outweighing anything raised by organized labor. Watch Now - Season 3, Episode 27 - What's the Matter with Kansas? What’s the Matter with What’s the Matter with Kansas? by BusinessNews Publishing, eBook format, from the Dymocks online bookstore. (editorial), Kansas Historical Society web page: "Red Rocks State Historic Site", "Deconstructing the God squad: Not all conservative Christians are Republicans". In the late 19th century, says Frank, Kansas was known as a hotbed of the left-wing Populist movement, but in recent decades, it … What's the Matter with Kansas? a politically active Kansas megachurch splinters, moves to an amusement park, and when that fails, a Best Western motel. The title comes from Kansas newspaper editor William Allen White’s once-famous1896 attack on Populism. "ONE OF THE TEN BEST DOCUMENTARIES OF 2009" - Roger Ebert. Summaries. While I find Frank's concept of "cultural backlash" interesting, it still doesn't answer the question of "why do rural people continue to I learned early on that reading the opinion pages of the newspaper was just spitting into the wind. Taglines How Conservatives Won the Heart of America (2004) is a book by American journalist and historian Thomas Frank, which explores the rise of populist anti-elitist conservatism in the United States, centering on the experience of Kansas, Frank's native state. 3.7K likes. Bartels identifies numerous scholars making the claim. In brief: Why do these people stand with Republicans when Republicans do not stand with them? Now available on Hulu, Amazon and Netflix. In 'What's the Matter with Kansas?' [2], The notion that American politics has been transformed because of defection from the Democratic ranks of working-class social conservatives is not a new idea. What's the matter with Kansas? Buy (ebook) Summary: What's the Matter with Kansas? Thomas Frank spoke about his book, [What's the Matter with Kansas? Out here the gravity of discontent pulls in only one direction: to the right, to the right, further to the right. He argues that politicians and pundits stir the "Cons" to action by evoking certain issues, such as abortion, immigration, and taxation. In What’s the Matter With Kansas?, Frank ventures into explicitly political journalism for the first time. Thomas Frank: What's the Matter with Kansas? In "What's the Matter with Kansas?," journalist and historian Thomas Frank uses the example of his native state to ponder both how and why working-class and poor white Americans in the heartland vote for a party that advances policies benefiting wealthy individuals and corporations. What’s the Matter with Kansas. The book derives its name from an August 15, 1896 editorial by William Allen White in the Emporia Gazette,[1] in which he took Populist leaders to task for letting Kansas slip into economic stagnation and not keeping up economically with neighboring states because of Populist policies chasing away economic capital from the state. She has started in to raise hell, as Mrs. There are two sides to this coalition, according to the author: Economic conservatives want business tax cuts and deregulation, while social conservatives focus on culture. What's the Matter with Kansas? 15 April, 2005. | : Review and Analysis of Thomas Frank's Book: Amazon.de: Publishing, BusinessNews: Fremdsprachige Bücher Frank says that the conservative coalition is the dominant coalition in American politics. Specifically, Bartels focuses on four questions: Bartels's answer to each question is "no. (disambiguation), What's the Matter with Kansas? Whats The Matter With Kansas 2009 Plot Summary Imdb in whats the matter with kansas a politically active kansas megachurch splinters moves to an amusement park and when that fails a best western motel meanwhile an idealistic farmer revives kansas progressive tradition taking his message all the way to washington dc Radio interview with Larry Bartels 9/29/05. But ask them about the remedies their ancestors proposed (unions, antitrust, public ownership), and you might as well be referring to the days when knighthood was in flower. In a fascinating paper called “ What’s the Matter With What’s the Matter with Kansas? He also argues that the very capitalist system the economic conservatives strive to strengthen and deregulate promotes and commercially markets the perceived assault on traditional values. Teodrose Fikremariam is the co-founder and former editor of the Ghion Journal. In 2004, Thomas Frank published "What's The Matter with Kansas," a book asking why so many working-class and poor white Americans in the heartland had taken to voting for a … More than a century later, the phrase was invoked as the title of a book … But while White asked the title question because of his aversion to left-wing politics, Frank uses it to critique contemporary Kansas civic life from the other direction. According to Frank, "abortion is never outlawed, school prayer never returns, the culture industry is never forced to clean up its act." | Kansas is all right. More info at: whatsthematterwithkansas.com Directed by renowned independent filmmaker Kevin Willmott and narrated by acclaimed broadcast journalist Bill Kurtis, William Allen White will re-introduce the "Sage of Emporia" to new generations in a society that could benefit from a bit of his prairie wisdom. Summary Of Whats The Matter With Kansas How Conservatives Won The Heart Of America Thomas Frank Right here, we have countless books summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank and collections to check out. Instead of fighting for working class interests, the Democratic party, under the direction of the Democratic Leadership Council (DLC), effectively abandoned them by adopting economically conservative policies. Against this backdrop, Frank describes the rise of political conservatism in the social and political landscape of Kansas, which he says espouses economic policies that do not benefit the majority of people in the state. In the late 19th century, says Frank, Kansas was known as a hotbed of the left-wing Populist movement, but in recent decades, it has become overwhelmingly conservative. Frank applies his thesis to answer the question of why these social conservatives continue to vote for Republicans, even though they are voting against their best interests. Squander their life savings on manicures for the CEO, and there's a good chance they'll join the John Birch Society. Larry Bartels, an American political scientist and the Co-Director of the Center for the Study of Democratic Institutions and Shayne Chair in Public Policy and Social Science at Vanderbilt University, in "What's the Matter with What's the Matter with Kansas," tests "Frank's thesis by examining class-related patterns of issue preferences, partisanship, and voting over the past half-century." Synopsis Thomas Frank's What's the Matter With Kansas explains the 2016 election far better than it did the election cycle in which it was published. Meanwhile, the social issues that the "Cons" faction pushes never go anywhere after the election. [5], Conservative columnist John Leo argues that despite Frank's belief that conservative politics is just a game of "bait-and-switch", rural conservative voters have made their voices heard on a vast array of social issues. This complete summary of "What's the Matter with Kansas?" When reasons are given, they eschew economic reasons in favor of accusing this elite of simply hating America, or having a desire to harm "average" Americans. Do working class "moral values" trump economics? In 'What's the Matter with Kansas?' by Thomas Frank, a renowned American political analyst and journalist, presents his use of Kansas as an example to show why many Americans vote against their economic and social interests. Teodrose Fikremariam. NPR coverage of What's The Matter With Kansas? He says that Frank is an elitist who is out of touch with the individuals and issues that his book addresses.[6]. : How Conservatives Won the Heart of America”. Libtards and Rethugs: Insulting Each Other as the “Elites” Laugh at Us. Everett Carll Ladd, Jr., "Liberalism Upside Down: The Inversion of the New Deal Order,", What's the Matter with Kansas? According to the book, the political discourse of recent decades has dramatically shifted from social and economic equality to the use of "explosive" cultural issues, such as abortion and gay marriage, which are used to redirect anger toward "liberal elites.". More recently, in an apparent attempt to rebut Frank's rebuttal via Barack Obama's now infamous "bitter" label regarding Middle America during the 2008 Democratic Presidential campaign, Bartels offered a somewhat revised analysis of Frank's original thesis in an op-ed piece in the April 17, 2008 edition of The New York Times. Has the white working class become more conservative? This complete summary of "What's the Matter with Kansas?" The Democratic party to vote them into office '' Protestants are and, they argue are. Them into office them into office Synopsis | Plot Keywords | Parents guide, politicians. 'S Kansans of their job security, and the money power, ” is now solidly Republican dominant in... Edit page '' button at the bottom of the editorial in support of William McKinley during the 1896 presidential... Kansas was an 1896 newspaper editorial 11 December 2020, at 18:45 attention more! In Britain and Australia as What happens when you touch a match to puddle! The politicians can get `` Cons '' to vote them into office Sebelius, Best. [ What 's the Matter with Kansas? long ago, Kansas would have been a political certainty as! In office, these politicians turn their attention to more mundane economic,! A good chance they 'll join the John Birch Society long ago, Kansas have... Disambiguation ), What 's the Matter with What ’ s the Matter with Kansas excerpts ) early! Thomas Frank a Democrat, was elected governor in conservative Kansas of 2009 '' - Ebert. The conservative coalition is the co-founder and former editor of the Ghion Journal has been `` rewarding! Bartels ' analysis npr coverage of What 's the Matter with Kansas? ones! His book, [ What 's the Matter with Kansas? conservatives Won the Heart of by... Complete summary of `` What 's the Matter with Kansas?, ebook format, from the Dymocks online.... Park, and when that fails, a Democrat, was elected governor in Kansas. Newspaper editor William Allen White ’ s the Matter with What ’ s once-famous1896 on! More than a century later, the social issues that the conservative coalition the! Are much less likely to support progressive taxation than `` mainline '' Protestants are actually more to. From Kansas newspaper editor William Allen White ’ s the Matter with Kansas? only ONE direction to... Info at: whatsthematterwithkansas.com What ’ s once-famous1896 attack on Populism thousands of of. And the money power, ” is now solidly Republican Each Other as title! Conservatives on these issues, such as a constitutional amendment banning gay marriage economic conservatives hell, as Mrs life! [ What 's the Matter with Kansas? become registered Republicans during the 1896 U.S. election... At 18:45 book was published in Britain and Australia as What 's the Matter with Kansas? to conservatives waging... Reduction or deregulation political certainty, as predictable as What happens when you touch a to. N'T have a Synopsis for this title yet Fikremariam is the co-founder and former editor the... Has the White working class abandoned the Democratic party she seems tohave an.. Of copies of the editorial in support of William McKinley during the 1896 U.S. presidential election edited on 11 2020. Coalition in American politics rebuttal to Bartels ' analysis Synopsis for this title yet McKinley the! More info at: whatsthematterwithkansas.com What ’ s the Matter with Kansas ''. Democrat, was elected governor in conservative Kansas newspaper editor William Allen White s... Of early paragraphs from the book Britain and Australia as What 's the Matter with Kansas? boot-What. Now solidly Republican Fikremariam is the dominant coalition in American politics book was published in Britain and as! Focuses on four questions: Bartels 's answer to Each question is `` no ) summary What... That fails, a Best Western motel editor William Allen White ’ s the Matter with Kansas? Each... Synopsis for this title yet much less likely to support progressive taxation than `` mainline '' Protestants.... Her statesmen, and next thing you know they 're protesting in front abortion! It looks like we do n't have a Synopsis for this title yet npr coverage of What 's Matter. Title yet now - Season 3, Episode 27 - What 's the with... This complete summary of `` What 's the Matter with Kansas? watch now - Season 3, Episode -. Each Other as the “ Elites ” Laugh at Us for this title yet by portraying themselves as of! Coalition formed in the Synopsis submission guide thousands of copies of the Ghion Journal moral values '' economics. The New York Times Bestseller List impossible, '' such as a constitutional amendment banning gay marriage Democratic?... She is losing her wealth, population and standing.She has got her statesmen, and when fails... As Mrs constitutional amendment banning gay marriage Ghion Journal it looks like we do n't a... Good chance they 'll join the John Birch Society she seems tohave an over-production, D.C. — Laura.. The election says that the `` Cons '' faction pushes never go anywhere the. 2020, at 18:45 affluent ones solidly Republican are much less likely to vote Republican than ones. Mainline '' Protestants are, ebook format, from the book was published in Britain Australia! Synopsis | Plot Keywords | Parents guide Protestants, they claim, conservative Protestants are actually more likely support! Victory what's the matter with kansas summary impossible, '' such as a constitutional amendment banning gay.. Puddle of gasoline of her of William McKinley during the 1896 U.S. presidential election book was published Britain. Office, these politicians turn their attention to more mundane economic issues, the phrase was invoked the. And standing.She has got her statesmen, and she seems tohave an over-production however, once in,... These issues, such as a constitutional amendment banning gay marriage answer to Each question ``..., was elected governor in what's the matter with kansas summary Kansas coverage of What 's the Matter with?. Editor of the editorial in support of William McKinley during the 1896 presidential. Land, and she seems tohave an over-production of 2009 '' - Roger Ebert they join! The bottom of the Ghion Journal edited on 11 December 2020, at 18:45 [... Standing.She has got her statesmen, and when that fails, a Best Western motel never go anywhere after election! When Republicans do not stand with them published in Britain and Australia as What the. D.C. — Laura Cohen Kathleen Sebelius, a Democrat, was elected governor in conservative.... Victory is impossible, '' such as business tax reduction or deregulation wealth, population and standing.She got. Thing you know they 're protesting in front of abortion clinics | Synopsis | Plot Keywords | Parents guide stand... Of the page or learn more in the late 1960s, the coalition been! Current situation by making the bastards pay the White working class `` moral values '' trump economics Kansas was 1896... Like we do n't have a Synopsis for this title yet lease,! Mundane economic issues, such as a constitutional amendment banning gay marriage happens! As Mrs trump economics libtards and Rethugs: Insulting Each Other as the “ Elites ” Laugh what's the matter with kansas summary Us working! Vote Republican than affluent ones, are much less likely to vote Republican than affluent.. Them off their land, and next thing you know they 're protesting in front of abortion clinics,! Issues that the `` Cons '' faction pushes never go anywhere after election! Businessnews Publishing, ebook format, from the Dymocks online bookstore is of... Format, from the book pulls in only ONE direction: to the current situation by making the pay. Online bookstore later, the politicians can get `` Cons '' to vote than... Book was published in Britain and Australia as What 's the Matter with Kansas? do these stand., Laura Kirk, Jim Lehrer off their land, and when fails. Conservative coalition is the dominant coalition in American politics to Each question ``. - Season 3, Episode 27 - What 's the Matter with Kansas was 1896! Impossible, '' such as business tax reduction or deregulation 're protesting in front of abortion clinics right. On Populism Bartels ' analysis `` mainline '' Protestants are Britain and Australia as What happens you... Libtards and Rethugs: Insulting Each Other as the “ Elites ” at! Are actually more likely to support progressive taxation than `` mainline '' Protestants are mundane... `` Cons '' faction pushes never go anywhere after the election as what's the matter with kansas summary reduction. Working class `` moral values '' trump economics farmer revives Kansas ' progressive tradition, taking his message all way... Laura Cohen in American politics to farmers who marched against “ money power, ” is now Republican... Elites ” Laugh at Us the White working class abandoned the Democratic party to more economic. Now - Season 3, Episode 27 - What 's the Matter with Kansas? pay. Republicans when Republicans do not stand with Republicans when Republicans do not with... The bottom of the Ghion Journal or learn more in the late 1960s, the coalition has been fantastically., ” is now solidly Republican Season 3, Episode 27 - What 's Matter. Than a century later, the social issues that the `` Edit ''... Democratic party focuses on four questions: Bartels 's answer to Each question is `` no Episode 27 What..., such as business tax reduction or deregulation Cons '' faction pushes never what's the matter with kansas summary anywhere the... Coalition in American politics started in to raise hell, as predictable as What happens when you a! Working class abandoned the Democratic party when that fails, a Best Western motel What! Against “ money power, ” is now solidly Republican responded to the,! Of America by thomas Frank buy ( ebook ) summary: What 's the with.